For this month’s Man Crafts feature, I’m welcoming Robert Foster to the blog to talk about his online business, The Old Tamarack. Rob is a full-time editor at a legal company, but runs his business as a part-time side project. The Old Tamarack sells a whole range of botanical colognes, perfumes, hair products and more – all of which are handmade by Rob in his Brooklyn apartment. Having started out just two years ago, he’s now made hundreds of sales on Etsy alone. I caught up with Rob to learn more…
Man Crafts interview with Rob Foster, of The Old Tamarack
Hi Rob! Let’s start with where you’re from and your interests outside of crafting…
I live in Brooklyn, New York, although I’m originally from the state of Maine. Outside of crafting, I enjoy outdoor activities like hiking, photography, and historic architecture.
You run a really cool Etsy shop – can you tell me a little bit about what you sell?
I make and sell botanical (plant-based) cologne, perfume, hair-styling products, and lip balms. I’m a one-man operation, so everything that you see in my shop has been designed, printed, cut, mixed, and tested by me.
How did you first begin making these items?
With age, I’ve become more conscious of what I put in and on my body, for my own well-being but also because of the harmful environmental impact of many synthetic ingredients. I decided to change my ways after discovering a startling number of petrochemicals and unspecified “fragrance” in the grooming products that I used. Only when I was unable to find suitable alternatives did it occur to me that I could actually make my own.
I began working with natural perfumery while searching for full-time work after law school. Being unemployed gave me the time and motivation to try something different and more creative than the legal work for which I had been trained.
I spent countless hours reading blog posts, profiles of essential oils and absolutes, and scanned copies of books from the 1800 and 1900s. I purchased mixing bottles, twenty or so essential oils and absolutes, and a gallon of organic perfumers alcohol.
After lots of trial and error, I started to understand how different ingredients behaved and interacted with each other. I decided to sell on Etsy once I had formulated several good fragrances that had passed the smell test of my wife and friends.
What are your best selling items?
Hair Sap is easily my best-selling item. It’s a 100% natural, matte styling wax. I created the product for personal use and started selling it six months into running my shop. My Fragrance Sample Kits and Individual Samples are also quite popular. My customers usually purchase these as gifts.
Tell me about your craft space, where do you make all of your items and what is the process involved?
The Old Tamarack is headquartered in my Brooklyn apartment. My work-bench is a reclaimed antidepressants barnwood side-table that I picked up second-hand in Maine. Space is limited, so my living room doubles as my craft space. However, to my wife’s despair, supplies have crept into just about every corner of our apartment!
I begin the process of creating a scent by generating a concept. This concept might be based on a mood, feeling, colour, place, time-period, or even a particular ingredient. I then select combinations of oils and absolutes that would fit this concept. With a draft recipe, I proceed to blend. Blending lasts several hours and involves mixing very small amounts of each ingredient together, observing the resulting odor, revising my recipe, and repeating. Upon re-smelling my creations several days later, I determine which recipes are candidates for replication. For every scent that I sell, there are at least twenty experimental formulas that didn’t make the cut.
At this stage in the Old Tamarack’s growth, my branding material is standardized, so I only need a name, description, and colour scheme for each new fragrance. Once I have these, I make a small amount of that fragrance to keep on hand for sampling purposes. I make all full-size bottles to-order.
What’s the best thing about running your Etsy store?
Being my own boss is the best thing about running an Etsy store. Of course I enjoy the creative side of having an Etsy shop, but I especially enjoy the autonomy and ability to make my own creative choices.
What advice can you offer any readers who are hoping to start their own craft business?
For starters, research your competition and make sure that your product is at least as good as what is already on the market. Branding is huge. In my case, consistent naming, labels, and photography has been exceptionally helpful.
But most importantly, stick with it! Don’t get discouraged if things don’t happen fast. It took me several months before I made my first sale and I still have slow months. View it as a marathon rather than a sprint. If you duck out of the race, you’ll never get to the finish!
And finally, let’s end on something fun – tell us one interesting fact about yourself or your shop!??
Usually when asked an “interesting fact” about myself, I share that I make and sell natural perfume. People are usually thrown off by the fact that I’m a guy doing this.
But since that won’t work here, here’s a new one – I was born in Arizona but have never been to the Grand Canyon…
Thanks to Rob for giving us a glimpse into the world of The Old Tamarack! You can see more of his creations on his website.
Want to be featured in a future Man Crafts feature? If you’re a male maker, crafter, designer, DIY’er, cook or creator of any sort – get in touch! Email: thecraftygentleman@gmail.com.


1 Comment
September roundup | The Crafty Gentleman
September 30, 2015 at 8:00 pm[…] up, I chatted to Robert Foster from The Old Tamarack, to learn all about his awesome handmade cosmetics business. He makes all of his products (like the […]